Genoa Pizza

Discover delicious flavors at Genoa Pizza in Palmyra, WI. Enjoy our buffalo chicken pizza, calzones, spaghetti, fresh salads, and more. Call +1 262-495-3480 for takeout or dine-in!

View MenuMake a Reservation

Welcome to Genoa Pizza

Taste the Difference.

Genoa Pizza
Genoa Pizza
Genoa Pizza
Genoa Pizza

Genoa Pizza welcomes you to a culinary adventure in Palmyra, Wisconsin. Located at 111 S 2nd St, this lively pizza restaurant is more than just a place to eat; it’s a community staple. The aroma of freshly baked pizzas mingles with laughter and friendly chatter, making every visit feel like a reunion with friends. Customers rave about the buffalo chicken pizza, a local favorite, alongside a generous selection of toppings and sauces that cater to every taste.

From classic spaghetti to mouthwatering calzones, each dish comes prepared with care. With busy evenings being a hallmark, visiting at off-peak times can help avoid the crowds, but the ambiance remains perfect at any hour. Genoa Pizza truly embodies the spirit of neighborhood dining.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

111 S 2nd St, Palmyra, WI 53156, United States

Phone

+1 262-495-3480

About

The Culinary Story

Genoa Pizza
Genoa Pizza
Genoa Pizza
Genoa Pizza

Since opening its doors, Genoa Pizza has become a beloved destination in Palmyra. The restaurant offers a wide range of delicious items, totaling 68 plates across various categories including pizzas, pastas, sandwiches, and salads. For fans of bold flavors, the buffalo chicken pizza stands out as a must-try, featuring a perfect balance of spicy sauce and rich toppings.

Customers often praise the thoughtful addition of quality ingredients, whether it’s the peppery bacon on the specialty pizzas or the selection of seasonal toppings that keep the menu fresh.

A typical week at Genoa Pizza sees a bustling crowd, especially on Thursdays at 5 PM when the restaurant reaches full capacity. Observing peak hours reveals a vibrant dinner atmosphere, with Tuesdays seeing unexpected popularity due to the enticing dinner specials.

It’s not uncommon to see families enjoying hearty meals together or friends celebrating the weekend with slices of their favorite pizzas.

Besides food, Genoa Pizza represents community spirit; special events and gatherings often take place, turning the restaurant into a gathering hub. Those who appreciate a good slice can chat about the best pizza styles or bonding over game nights and sports updates. For anyone in Palmyra, Genoa Pizza is more than just a place to eat—it’s a slice of local culture.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday3-9 PM
  • Monday3-9 PM
  • Tuesday3-10 PM
  • Wednesday3-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-10 PM
  • Friday3-10 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-10 PM

Genoa Pizza offers a diverse menu that expands beyond just pizza. Customers can indulge in savory appetizers like mozzarella sticks and cheese garlic bread, perfect for sharing with friends or as a starter. The sandwich selection includes hearty choices like the Italian Beef and Cheesy Beef, ideal for a quick yet satisfying meal. For those in the mood for pasta, the family-style servings of spaghetti and baked ravioli are popular picks that satisfy even the biggest appetites.

Dining at Genoa Pizza means enjoying a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere. The restaurant is known for its speedy service, especially during peak hours.

With the busiest times commonly falling around Thursday evenings, planning a visit slightly earlier or later might enhance the experience. The staff radiate warmth, making newcomers feel like part of the family. Whether dining in or taking out, Genoa Pizza’s commitment to quality and flavor shines through in every bite.

Genoa Pizza

Nestled on S 2nd St, Genoa Pizza boasts a welcoming exterior that invites diners in. The signage is bright, capturing the attention of passersby and promising delicious meals within. The outdoor seating area offers a relaxed vibe, perfect for warm-weather dining while enjoying the sights and sounds of Palmyra. Families and friends gather here to enjoy meals al fresco, creating lively conversations filled with laughter.

This casual atmosphere resonates with both locals and travelers alike, making Genoa Pizza a popular spot for unwinding after a long day. The cheerful decor adds to the inviting feel, making it easy to sit back and enjoy a delightful meal in good company.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

They do a fantastic job! The food is so-o good. The pizza is delicious, the Lasagna is top notch and the garlic bread is amazing! They deliver and their delivery people are great too! Seriously, try it, you will be happy.

C
Cory Y.

We were camping at Horseman's Camp - ordered some appetizers, pizza and salad - ALL was excellent! Best pizza crust we've had in ages!! Super nice, friendly service!

N
Nora C.

Hey, truck driver here. Ordered a spaghetti with ground beef instead of meatballs. Unbaked. I had forgot i didn't have any utensils! When the driver showed up I asked if there was any utensils and he said no. I told him I had no way to eat it then (except caveman style). He offered to run back and get me some and was back in about 10 minutes. I'm Very surprised and appreciative that he did. The spaghetti was incredible! Best i have had since my moms spaghetti. Sauce was not to sweet. Noodles were nice and soft. And plenty of ground beef! Will be ordering again!

D
Duttin J.

Genoa's is by far my favorite pizza in the world! And I've done a bit of travelling. They have amazing salads and I am always impressed with their pizza. I moved out of town, but I still make a 45 minute drive (one-way) just for their Tuesday "buy one pizza, get one free"! Thank you for being so delicious :)

J
Jax B.

We always share the chef salad! So many layers, so yummy. We Love It!

S
Shelly H.

This place is great. Their pizza is excellent and breaded mushrooms are one of the best I ever tasted. Friendly and great service. Ive ordeded from here twice now one carryout and one delivery both fast and the food was hot.

S
Samantha S.